The Mayor of Old Town

632 S Mason St, Fort Collins, CO 80524, USA

About The Mayor of Old Town

4.6 / 5

from reviews

Is this your business?

    Chuck Baumgart
    February 18, 2024

    A dated-looking venue with poor parking options, but definitely worth the effort to get in and try their food and beer options! An incredible selection of over 80 beers on tap, focused on Colorado breweries, but complemented by some excellent out of state choices. The food is not just your typical pub grub. They've elevated some classic dishes with amazing sauces and flavors. Don't miss the truffle fries and the schnitzel sandwich with habanero jelly, slaw.

    Christa Allen
    May 07, 2024

    First and foremost, the bar is stunning and incredibly impressive with the amount of taphandles available! They offer a broad range of local beers, ciders, and hard seltzers. We came during lunch and our service was prompt and friendly and the building looked quite clean. Our food landed and upon arrival I wasn't overly impressed with the presentation, however the taste was definitely meeting expectations! If in the area, I definitely recommend trying.

    Abby Sparks
    July 06, 2024

    *** In response to the restaurants comment, the issue was not the cake. It was with how their employee treated us when we were unaware of the policy. There was every opportunity for this situation to have been handled better.*** Please read this whole post it's going to be a long one. It was our first time in for a celebration. The food and drinks were really good-but our interaction with our waitress Dev ruined the experience. We were the first customers in for the day. Throughout our whole meal she seemed annoyed with our group, especially when it took my older relatives a second to order. The main conflict that ruined our experience was that we brought in a birthday cake (at the time we did not know this was not aloud). Our waitress said nothing to us, as we asked for extra plates, lit a candle, even sang happy birthday. She even came and cleared out plates while we were eating the cake. Right before we got our check Dev came up to the table. Instead of politely informing us that it was against the restaurant's policy she instead just said, "I need a piece of that cake." Our group all thought that it was her just joking and wanting to be in on the birthday cake. She then repeated herself in a less friendly way. We asked if she was serious because we didn't understand. She said that the staff needed to try it for cross contamination, (again instead of explaining that what we did was against policy). The conversation ended up going south. We asked if we could speak to the manager. Which she came back to say he was too busy and could not speak with us. We were one of maybe 4/5 tables in the restaurant. I asked for a card or his name so we could at least call back to talk to him. She would not give me either. While we were having this conversation, the manager walked out with his laptop. We asked if we could have a word and he said he was busy because he had a zoom call. However we were able to chat with him for a moment. We tried to explain we felt bad about the cake and did not mean to create a conflict but we didn't appreciate how Dev decided to approach us about it. Due to how we were treated we will not be coming back or recommending this restaurant to anyone. We live 5 minutes away from The Mayor, if we would have been told it was against policy for the cake to be eaten in the restaurant we would have packed it up and taken it home to eat with family.

    Damon Tighe
    March 20, 2024

    C great place for beers and Americana food in a fun atmosphere: sort of a re-vamped dinner aesthetic. Huge beer list. Food was solid and good sized portions

    Kate C.
    July 01, 2024

    Good food, server was wonderful. Of course, beer selection was amazing. Loved the poutine! Heard they charged for sitting outside? That can't be true... We sat inside, so don't know. Be aware, they are in that group of restaurants that charge the customer a fee for kitchen staff so they don't have to pay them. Don't care for that. Overall, a nice visit, but ......

    The Mayor of Old Town

    Our Address

    632 S Mason St, Fort Collins, CO 80524, USA

    See Your Business Here!

    For more information on our listings, advertising, coupons, and marketing plans, please contact us today!