Panhandler’s Pizza

2721 S College Ave, Fort Collins, CO 80521, USA

About Panhandler’s Pizza

4.2 / 5

from reviews

Is this your business?

    Jeff Rubenstein
    December 15, 2023

    $45 for a large four topping pizza?! I was blown away during my recent visit that a pizza could be so expensive. We’ve been coming to Panhandler’s‘s pizza in northern Colorado and more specifically Fort Collins Colorado for more than 30 years. The original location at campus west was a unique blend of quality pizza, great service, and a fantastic atmosphere. the pizza is still fantastic and probably the best pizza in all of Fort Collins if you’re looking for the classic deep dish. However, during my most recent visit to the newer location in mid town, Fort Collins, not only was I shocked at the price of the pizza, I was shocked at the number of dirty tables with dishes piled up on them throughout the entire restaurant. I would say about 90% of the tables were dirty and had not been cleaned. There was one person working behind the counter, taking orders, and responsible for keeping the front of the house clean. I understand that food cost is high right now but $45 for a pizza is way too much. I’d like to say that we will continue to go here for Pizza but given the previous experience I’m not so sure that we will. I give a five star rating for the awesome pizza.

    Jennifer Harrar
    April 22, 2024

    I literally couldn't stop talking to the manager about how beyond grateful we were here today! My family stopped in on a whim and figured we'd take it to go, or maybe there was a boneless chicken wings here option for our child with food allergies. Worst case, I'd make food at home otherwise to enjoy pizza at home together. The manager overheard our convos and told us not only did they have gluten free crust, but they had the liquid vegan cashew cheese to offer too!!! We have a milk allergy on top of celiac. I couldn't even believe it!! My jaw dropped. A pizza place my kid could eat at safely was a dream come true. She told the kitchen staff, who took all the precautions to change our utensils, pans etc. and he got his own personal 10 inch. We are so forever grateful for this restaurant and Lonnie (manager?) It is so difficult to eat out lately that we just don't. It isn't worth the risk, the cost, the hassle and confusion and all the ordering switches.. but this place handles it with so much grace and we felt incredibly lucky that they had these offerings. The price was a bit high to come regularly but honestly, for gf and DF offerings on a treat basis, it's priceless at that point!! @panhandlerspizza in Fort Collins. ,❤️

    Taylor Francis
    June 14, 2023

    Panhandlers was so delicious!! Its thick crust and generous amounts of toppings left me wanting to try every flavor! We got the Dsayuno breakfast pizza, the beggar with Chicago style sauce, and a large cheese. The breakfast pizza includes green chili, sausage, bell peppers, onions, eggs, and gooey amazing cheese! It was our overall favorite pizza. They were all incredibly delicious!! It is a little pricey, but most definitely worth it!!!!

    Hannah B
    January 12, 2024

    EDIT: I did recieve a refund and someone reached out to remedy this. Very happy with how this was handled and we look forward to eating more pizza! Great pizza! We absolutely love going here. However, the last time we ordered a pizza and paid extra for chicken, the chicken was so dried out and hard it was inedible. I reached out via email to the store but never heard back :(. We paid 30 dollars for a small and would have liked to at least get a refund for the crouton-like chicken that we paid extra for.

    Anita Haviland
    July 03, 2024

    Great pizza! The sausage is made just for them. Dough made fresh daily and cheese is grated not bought grated. Waited on by Makaila who was pleasant and helpful. Loved the manager Lani. Music every Tuesday!

    Panhandler’s Pizza

    Our Address

    2721 S College Ave, Fort Collins, CO 80521, USA

    See Your Business Here!

    For more information on our listings, advertising, coupons, and marketing plans, please contact us today!